Sunday, April 11, 2021

Moreland & Craig on Brainfishing for the Mental

 "One might think that the day will come in which scientists have so precisely correlated mental and brain states that a scientist could, indeed, know better than I whas is going on in my mental life by simply reading my brain states. But this is not true. Why? In order for scientists to develop a detailed chart correlating specific mental and physical states,  he must ask his experimental subjects what is going on inside them as he reads the brain monitor. Thus any correlation chart will be epistemically dependent on and weaker than a subject's own introspective knowledge of his conscious states because the chart is dependent on the accuracy of experimental subjects' reports of their own consciousness."

--J. P. Moreland and William Lane Craig, Philosophical Foundations for a Christian Worldview, Revised edition, IVP Academic, 2017, page 214.